Pine Rest Christian Mental Helath Servcies logo
header photo 2
header photo 2
header photo 3
   
             
 

Change the Text Size:

Larger Text

Smaller Text

 

May I Be Angry With God?

by Robert A. Nykamp, MDiv, MS

Many of us were taught, "You're not allowed to be angry at God." In fact, most of us learned we were not to be angry with our mother, father, brother, sister, schoolteacher, or friends. Good Christian boys and girls are forgiving and caring. They do not show anger. It's wrong to fight and argue. When you show your anger in actions that are hurtful or nasty, you need to confess your sins quickly, say, "I'm sorry," and be a pleasant person.

However, most of us soon discovered we live in a world where other people are not very pleasant. Other boys and girls called us names. We were "chicken" if we didn't fight. People served first in the cafeteria line were those who pushed ahead. Nice people finished last.

Therefore we often faced a dilemma. We were angry in a natural and appropriate way, and yet we were not to express that anger. We experienced hurt and pain-even with God-and yet we were not to put that anger into words or actions. The only alternative for many of us was to turn the anger in on ourselves. We experienced depression-feeling sad, lonely, frustrated and hurt.

Often we would ask, "Isn't being angry really God's way? Is God so opposed to anger?" Many boys, girls, teenagers and adults often silently raise these questions. The Bible says God was angry. When the people of Israel made a gold calf, God said to Moses, "Now let me alone that my wrath may burn hot against them and I may consume them" (Exodus 32:10). Jesus was indignant with the disciples when they kept the children from him (Mark 10:14). He turned over the tables of the money-changers in the temple. In fact, at times it appears God would be more comfortable with our anger than would our parents or other significant people in our lives.

Let me suggest a new framework for the experience of anger. Many people who are struggling with hurt, pain, and frustration find they can obtain health and wholeness if they look at anger from a new perspective.

Anger is God's gift to you and me to help us become what God wants us to be. Anger becomes an indicator that our needs and desires are not being met, and that we may take constructive actions to find a wholesome and meaningful relationship with God and with others. Scripture says that God doesn't want us to repress our anger, but to express it in ways that will not be sinful (Ephesians 4:26). This expression contributes to our growth and development with one another into mature wholeness as members of the family of God. Ephesians 4:15,16 says the processing of our truth within a relationship enables us to grow together into Christ, so in maturity and stability we can express our unity in a functional way in Him.

Anger releases our energy. It enables us to be activated within a relationship to bring about a helpful give-and-take. Processing anger enables God's people to grow in relationship with God and with others so the power of the Spirit can produce the fruits and gifts in a constructive way in our lives. Let's look at a couple of people to understand how this might work.

Jean is in her late thirties. She finds it difficult to manage the pressures and hurt in her life. Fifteen years ago, her father died very suddenly of a heart attack at age 51. Jean has experienced a great deal of repressed anger recently because she misses her father so much.

Jean has an older sister, Sue. Their mother is often critical of Jean. Jean remembers Dad was often the buffer for Mother's angry, critical comments. He often supported Jean as she participated in sports activities. Sue usually did everything right in the home, in church, and in school. She kept her room neat and clean. She practiced the piano. She said her prayers regularly. Sue was a model person and everything seemed to fit together for her. But Jean loved being outdoors, working with her dad. She loved sports-especially volleyball and tennis. However, Jean found it difficult to manage money constructively. Dad always seemed to have an understanding comment and helpful idea.

For a few years after Dad died, things seemed to go okay. Jean was able to finish college and enjoyed being a physical therapist. But then things went wrong.

The pressures at work were difficult for her to manage. Eventually she needed to be hospitalized and went on disability .Her car was damaged in an accident. She tore ligaments in her knee playing softball and had to have surgery. She developed pain in her shoulder after a second car accident. Her question is, "God, why are you doing all of this to me?"

At times, Jean's anger is so strong that she bangs her hand against the wall or knocks her head on the floor. She feels guilty that she experiences this anger toward God, toward her mother, toward her sister. She misses her father.

If our premise is correct-that anger is God's gift to Jean to help her become what God wants her to be-then she has to be able to accept some facts. She misses her father. She hates not being employed. She is disgusted with physical limitations. She needs to have healing and restoration. She must be able to find the right kinds of support and relationships to experience God's love and grace.

Jean is afraid of relationships with other people. Even though she desperately wants to relate to both men and women in open ways, she thinks they will criticize or abandon her. Jean must accept that God is big enough to take her anger. God intends for her to have meaningful relationships. God wants her to have a constructive vocation. She must be able to take the necessary risks to become God's whole person with limitations in her own world.

Therefore, our second important premise is that God is big enough to take our anger and wants to help us process it so we can become mature functioning people in God's world. When Job expressed his anger at not being understood by his friends and experiencing all the deprivation in his life unjustly, God said, "Job, let's talk about it. Stand up, and let's process your anger and your frustration in a constructive way. Let's go for a walk in the world of nature. Let's discuss your understanding of how the miracles of nature unfold day by day and year by year" (Job 38:1-12 ff).

Think of Jonah sitting in the desert outside Nineveh, angry because he knew God was not going to destroy that city .God came to Jonah and asked, "Do you do well to be angry?" Jonah answered, "Yes, I do well to be angry." God said, "Fine, let's process your anger." God and Jonah explored the meaning of his anger when there was no shade because a worm destroyed the tree. God said, "I would like you to understand my side of the story."

Job and Jonah both came to the point of realizing that God was big enough to take their anger. They saw that God would not be pushed out of experiencing with them the frustration and hurt from living in a world where sin attacks God's people. God is ready to process that anger to the point where we can experience hope, justice, freedom, and fulfillment.

Bill, in his late forties, has come to a point of hopelessness and despair. He questions whether it's worth living. Bill said he always felt different as long as he could remember. He cries easily. His siblings and friends ridiculed him for being a "cry-baby." He was uncoordinated, so he never did well in sports. Bill was usually the last one chosen for a team activity. He enjoyed music and became an excellent tenor. He graduated from college and became a teacher.

But soon he found the pressures of being a perfectionist led to a depression which kept him from having a regular work record. Finally after a couple of extended periods of treatment for his depression, he quit his job. His wife found it difficult to cope with his depression. Finally they separated. They decided he could better care for their children. She worked full-time and gave him some child-support money.

He felt it was important for his children to have a Christian education. Working part-time, he tried to maintain a home and relationship with his children that would be appropriate and fulfilling. But he soon found himself in extensive debt-owing thousands of dollars. The school ended services to his children. Bill decided it was no longer worthwhile trying to make ends meet. He tried to end his life.

He became aware that he was really very angry with God, but was afraid to express his anger. He was angry that God had created him with different gifts and abilities. He was angry that God did not help his wife be understanding and stay in the marriage. He was angry with the school administration that they would not trust him to pay tuition.

It was only as Bill could begin to accept that his anger was a gift to help him become a person who could accept his own creation and his tenderness, and then to accept that God was big enough to process his anger with him, that Bill could become more realistic and dependable, and could apply these principles in his life.

Both Bill and Jean needed support over an extended period to put these principles with anger into operation. There were no simple, easy answers. Life did not just fall into place.

God does not promise to quickly remove the anger, hurt, and pain. But God does promise to walk with us through the experiences of anger. Doing so enables us to become individuals who can express our gifts and commitments in ways that will bring fulfillment and growth with God and with others.

 

Augsburger, David W. Anger and Assertiveness in Pastoral Care. Philadelphia: Fortress Press. 1979.

Carter, Les. Good 'n' Angry. Grand Rapids: Baker Book House. 1983.

Lerner, Harriet Goldhor, Ph.D. The Dance of Anger. New York: Harper & Row. 1985.

Walters, Richard P. Anger, Yours and Mine, and What to Do About It. Grand Rapids: Zondervan Publishing House. 1981.

Wolff, Pierre. May I Hate God? New York: Paulist Press. 1979.

 

Search Today magazines:
    Help 




TODAY: Anger — Potential for Growth

Robert A. Nykamp, MDiv, MS, is Director of Pastoral Services. He has served at Pine Rest as a chaplain since 1981, both with an inpatient unit and a partial hospitalization program. Previously Nykamp served three congregations in the Reformed Church in America and taught at Western Theological Seminary for 12 years. He and his wife, Erma, live in Holland, Michigan.